solutio

Solutio constitutes one of seven major alchemical operations as distinguished by Edinger, each one a center of an elaborate symbol system making up the principle content of all culture-products. The author's cluster diagram (fig. 003.00) of solutio is shown below:

(xx)

AOP Pg 047 (xx) Cluster Diagram Solutio

Cluster Diagram: Solutio

Author's Diagram

(a)

The operation of solutio is one of the major procedures in alchemy. One text says, “Solutio is the root of alchemy.” Another says, “Until all be made water, perform no operation.” In many places the whole opus is summarized by the phrase “Dissolve and coagulate.” Just as calcinatio pertains to the element fire, coagulatio to the element earth, and sublimatio to the element air, so solutio pertains to water. Basically, solutio turns a solid into a liquid. The solid seems to disappear into the solvent as if it had been swallowed up

AOP ¶ 0
(b)

There are seven major aspects of solutio symbolism:

AOP ¶ 0
(b-1)

Return to the womb or primal state

AOP ¶ 0
(b-2)

Dissolution, dispersal, dismemberment

AOP ¶ 0
(b-3)

Containment of a lesser thing by a greater

AOP ¶ 0
(b-4)

Rebirth, rejuvenation, immersion in the creative energy flow

AOP ¶ 0
(b-5)

Purification ordeal

AOP ¶ 0
(b-6)

Solution of problems

AOP ¶ 0
(b-7)

Melting or softening process

AOP ¶ 0
(b-8)

These different aspects overlap. Several or all of them may make up different facets of a single experience. Basically it is the ego's confrontation with the unconscious that brings about solutio

AOP ¶ 0
(b-9)

Both patient and agent must be soft and fluid

AOP ¶ 0

RETURN TO THE WOMB

FOR REBIRTH

(c)

For the alchemist, solutio often meant the return of differentiated matter to its original undifferentiated statethat is, to prima materia. Water was thought of as the womb and solutio as a return to the womb for rebirth

AOP ¶ 0
(d)

First matter, or prima materia, is an idea that the alchemists inherited from the pre-Socratic philosophers. In Thales, and also in many creation myths, water is the original material out of which the world is created. The alchemists thought that a substance could not be transformed unless it were first reduced to prima materia. One text says, “Bodies cannot be changed except by reduction into their first matter.” This procedure corresponds to what takes place in psychotherapy. The fixed, static aspects of the personality allow for no change. They are established and sure of their rightness. For transformation to proceed, these fixed aspects must first be dissolved or reduced to prima materia. This is done by the analytic process, which examines the products of the unconscious and puts the established ego attitudes into question

AOP ¶ 0

ALCHEMICAL RECIPES FOR

THE SOLUTIO OPERATION

(e)

Alchemical recipes for the solutio operation give us a picture of a descent into the unconscious, which is the maternal womb from which the ego is born. It is the prima materia prior to the differentiation of the elements by consciousness. Some texts describe the procedure as a very pleasant process. There are others which express it much more negatively. For instance, consider this solutio-dismemberment recipe: “The body of that woman [who slays her husbands] is full of weapons and poison. Let a grave be dug for that dragon, and let that woman be buried with him, he being chained fast to that woman; and the more he winds and coils himself around her, the more will he be cut to pieces by the female weapons which are fashioned in the body of the woman. And when he sees that he is mingled with the limbs of the woman, he will be certain of death, and will be changed wholly into blood” ( CW14: par. 15 )

AOP ¶ 0
(f)

This grisly image expresses how a fairly well-developed ego might experience solutio. An immature ego may find it pleasant to surrender to containment in a blissful regression; however, at a later stage of development the prospect of solutio will generate great anxiety because the hard won state of ego autonomy is being threatened with dissolution. A blissful solutio is the most dangerous one. It corresponds to Neumann's concept of uroboric incest

AOP ¶ 0

LONGING FOR BLISSFUL SOLUTIO

(g)

An example of the longing for blissful solutio is Siegfried's yearning for union with Brünnhilde in Wagner's The Ring of the Nibelung (fig. 003.01)

AOP ¶ 0
(g)

AOP Pg 049 (g) FigNo003.01

(g)

Siegfried and the Rhine Maidens

(g)

Rackham, Color Illustrations for Wagner's “Ring”

(g-1)

Another example is the final death song of Isolde in Act 3, Scene 4 of Wagner's great solutio drama, Tristan and Isolde

AOP ¶ 0
(h)

Our alchemical text is a mixture of images, as often happens in alchemy. It is a combination of solutio and coniunctio. Sol and Luna are being dissolved and united at the same time. This corresponds to a common type of alchemical picture in which the king and queen are bathing together in the mercurial fountain. An outstanding sequence of pictures of this type is found in the Rosarium Philosophorum (fig. 003.02)

AOP ¶ 0
(h)

AOP Pg 051 (h) FigNo003.02

(h)

The King and Queen in the Bath

(h)

Mylius, Philosophia reformata, (1622)

(h-1)

As our text indicates, the solutio has a twofold effect: it causes one form to disappear and a new regenerated form to emerge. The dissolution of the old one is often described in negative imagery and is associated with the nigredo. For instance, Philalethes says: “The blackness becomes more pronounced day by day until the substance assumes a brilliant black color. This black is a sign that the dissolution is accomplished”

AOP ¶ 0

SOLUTIO AS

A MORTIFICATIO

(i)

Solutio thus may become a mortificatio. This is understandable because that which is being dissolved will experience the solutio as an annihilation of itself. It is here that the saying of Heraclitus applies: “To souls it is death to become water.” However, solutio leads on to the emergence of a rejuvenated new form, and when this aspect is emphasized the tone is positive. For instance, The Golden Treatise of Hermes says: O, blessed watery pontic form, that dissolvest the elements!For when, by the power of the water, the composition is dissolved, it is the day of the restoration; then darkness and Death fly away from them, and Wisdom proceeds ( Atwood, Hermetic Philosophy and Alchemy. p. 122 )

AOP ¶ 0
(j)

Often solutio is performed on the king. There is, for instance, the image of the drowning king, since drowning is a synonym for solutio (fig. 003.03) . One text has the drowning king (or king's son) say, “Whosoever will free me from the waters and lead me to dry land, him will I proper with everlasting riches” ( CW12: par. 434 ). Psychologically, the meaning is that the old ruling principle, which has undergone solutio is calling out to be coagulated again in a new, regenerated form, saying that it has quantities of libido (riches) at its disposal

AOP ¶ 0
(j)

AOP Pg 052 (j) FigNo003.03

(j)

Solutio of the King

(j)

Background: Drowning King Calling for Help. Foreground: The King Reborn. Trismosin, Splendor Solis, (1582)

(k)

Another text speaks of dropsy, an inner drowning. The king asked for a drink of water saying: “`I demand the water which is closest to my heart, and which likes me above all things.' When the servant brought it, the king drank so much that `all his limbs were filled and all his veins inflated, and he himself became discoloured'`I am heavy and my head hurts me, and it seems to me as though all my limbs were falling apart.' He demanded to be placed in a heated chamber where he could sweat the water out. But when, after a while, they opened the chamber he lay there as if dead” ( CW14: par. 357 )

AOP ¶ 0
(l)

Jung comments on this text: “The king personifies a hypertrophy of the ego which calls for compensation.His thirst is due to his boundless concupiscence and egotism. But when he drinks he is overwhelmed by the waterthat is, by the unconscious” ( CW14: par. 365 )

AOP ¶ 0
(m)

As Jung suggests, the king refers to the egoat least the dominant or ruling principle according to which the ego is structured. The king is dissolving in his own surfeit; that is, inflation is the cause and agent of solutio. A swollen ego is dissolved by its own excess. Its dissolution leads the way to a possible rejuvenation on a sounder basis

AOP ¶ 0

KING DROWNS IN THE

FOUNTAIN OF VENUS

(n)

In another text the king is described as drowning in the fountain of Venus. In this poem Venus is identified with the fountain, the mother and bride of the king, in which her “fixed” father is drowned

AOP ¶ 0
(n-1)

In this case the agent of dissolution is the Eros principle, Venus or Aphrodite. Her mythology has important relations to water by virtue of the fact that she was born out of the sea (fig. 003.04) . Her dangerous powers of solutio are represented by seductive mermaids or water nymphs who lure men to death by drowning. An impressive example of this theme occurred in a dream of a young man who was thinking of leaving his wife and young children to marry a seductive woman. He dreamed:

AOP ¶ 0
(n-1)

AOP Pg 054 (n-1) FigNo003.04

(n-1)

The Birth of Aphrodite

(n-1)

c. 460 B.C., Rome, Terme Museum

Dream:

Seductive Woman

(n-2)

I am in an underpass where people pass to and fro from the beach. Here are sold the usual recreation goodies: enormous lollypops, popcorn, pretzels a foot or more in length, and crackerjacks. Two of my children are with me (the two youngest). A beautiful woman beckons me to the sea and I leave the children in a hawker's stand munching pretzels. The dream ends as I stand midway between the sea and the stand

A FATAL SOLUTIO

(n-3)

A classical example of a fatal solutio occurs in the story of Hylas. During the expedition of the Argonauts, Hylas, the beautiful favorite of Heracles, was sent to fetch water. He was pulled into a pool by water nymphs and was never seen again. Here the solutio image accompanies a homoerotic entanglement, the attachment between Heracles and Hylas (fig. 003.05)

AOP ¶ 0
(n-3)

AOP Pg 055 (n-3) FigNo003.05

(n-3)

Hylas and the Nymphs

(n-3)

John William Waterhouse. Manchester, England, City Art Gallery

THE EROTIC SOLUTIO

(n-4)

The Old Testament provides examples of the erotic solutio that combine the themes of woman, bath, and the dissolution of the masculine. David spied Bathsheba bathing ( 2 Sam. 11 : 2 ), and thus began the dissolution of that man of integrity (fig. 003.06) . In the apocryphal text of Daniel and Susanna, the two elders lustfully approach Susanna in her bath and meet their downfall after giving perjured testimony (fig. 003.07)

AOP ¶ 0
(n-4)

AOP Pg 055 (n-4) FigNo003.06

(n-4)

Bathsheba

(n-4)

Rembrandt. Paris, the Louvre

(n-4)

AOP Pg 055 (n-4) FigNo003.07

(n-4)

Susanna and the Elders

(n-4)

Tintoretto. Vienna, Gemäldegalerie

(n-5)

These images tell us that love and / or lust are agents of solutio. This corresponds to the fact that a particular psychic problem or stage of development often remains arrested or stuck until the patient falls in love. Then abruptly the problem is dissolved. Although new complications appear, life has begun to flow again. It has been liquified

AOP ¶ 0

CONTAINMENT OF A LESSER THING

BY A GREATER THING

(o)

One alchemist defined solutio this way: “Solution is the action of any body, which, by certain laws of innate sympathy, assimilates anything of a lower class to its own essence.” Understood psychologically, this definition states that the dissolving agent will be a superior, more comprehensive viewpointone that can act as a containing vessel for the smaller thing

AOP ¶ 0

“THE CONTAINED AND THE CONTAINER”

PATIENT AND ANALYST

(o-1)

Jung's concept of “the contained and the container” applies here. In relating to a more complex personality, Jung says: “the simpler personality is surrounded, if not actually swamped, by it; he is swallowed up in his more complex partner and cannot see his way out. It is an almost regular occurrence for a woman to be wholly contained, spiritually, in her husband, and for a husband to be wholly contained, emotionally, in his wife. One could describe this as the problem of the `contained' and the `container' ” ( CW17: par. 331 )

AOP ¶ 0
(p)

Whatever is larger and more comprehensive than the ego threatens to dissolve it. Internally, the unconscious as the latent Self or totality of the psyche can dissolve the ego. Externally, an individual with a larger consciousness than one's own can bring about solutio. For instance, a man who had recently come in contact with Jung's ideas and had fallen under their sway had this dream: He dreamed that he fell into Lake of Zurich. A group, a school, or a party may also be the dissolving agent. A group collective can easily attract the projection of the Self and swallow up the individual who succumbs to it. Identification with political parties or religious creeds would be examples of solutio within a group

AOP ¶ 0
(q)

In the process of psychotherapy it usually happens that the ego of the patient encounters in the therapist a more comprehensive standpoint, which has a dissolving effect. This happening often leads to a partial state of containment of the patient by the therapist and is a common cause of the transference. Whenever a one-sided attitude encounters a larger attitude that includes the opposites, the former, if it is open to influence, is dissolved by the latter and goes into a state of solutio. This explains why a more comprehensive standpoint is often experienced as a threat. It feels as though one were drowning, and hence it will be resisted. Such resistance is valid and necessary and should be respected

AOP ¶ 0
(r)

The psychotherapist must always be aware of the possibility that the patient may need to be shielded from the psychotherapist's more comprehensive attitude. Basically it is the Self, either experienced from within or as a projection on an individual or a group from without, that is the agency of solutio

AOP ¶ 0

REBIRTH, REJUVENATION,

CREATIVE IMMERSION

(s)

Bath, shower, sprinkling, swimming, immersion in water, and so forth, are all symbolic equivalents for solutio that appear commonly in dreams. All of these images relate to the symbolism of baptism, which signifies a cleansing, rejuvenation immersion in an energy and viewpoint transcending the ego, a veritable death and rebirth

AOP ¶ 0
(t)

The I Ching has a hexagram, number 59, which might have been named “solutio.” Wilhelm calls it “Dispersion or Dissolution.” Part of the commentary reads as follows:

AOP ¶ 0
(t-1)

Religious forces are needed to overcome the egotism that divides men. The common celebration of the great sacrificial feasts and sacred riteswas the means employed by the great rulers to unite men. The sacred music and the splendor of the ceremonies aroused a strong tide of emotion that was shared by all hearts in unison, and that awakened a consciousness of the common origin of all creatures. In this way disunity was overcome and rigidity dissolvedEgotism and cupidity isolate men. Therefore the hearts of men must be seized by a devout emotion. They must be shaken by a religious awe in face of eternity ( Wilhelm, trans., The I Ching or Book of Changes, pp. 227ff. )

THE LESSER AND GREATER

ASPECT OF ALCHEMICAL OPERATIONS

(u)

Each of the alchemical operations has a lesser and a greater aspect, just as it has both a negative and a positive side. The fire of calcinatio can be experienced as hell fire or the inspiration of the Holy Ghost. The same applies to solutio. One text says: “You are to know that, although the solution is one, yet in it there may be distinguishing a first, and a second.The first solution isthe reduction of it to its First Matter; the second is that perfect solution of body and spirit at the same time, in which the solvent and the thing solved always abide together, and with this solution of the body there takes place simultaneously a consolidation of the spirit” ( Waite, trans., The Hermetic Museum 1 : 40 )

AOP ¶ 0
(v)

The greater solutio thus involves a transposition of the opposites; the solution of the body brings about a consolidation of the spirit.This is profound and paradoxical symbolism. The most obvious meaning is that a release from concrete particulars promotes a realization of universals. However, the paradoxical play of opposites means ultimately that the procedure leads to the Selfthe transpersonal center of the psyche that unites and reconciles the opposites

AOP ¶ 0

WATER AS THE

GOAL OF SOLUTIO

(w)

We are thus brought, finally, to the ultimate in solutio symbolism, the idea of the water that is the goal of the process. Several terms are used for this liquid version of the Philosophers' Stone:

AOP ¶ 0

`Aqua permanens'

`Elixir vitae'

`Tincture'

`Philosophical water'

`Universal solvent'

`Divine water,' and so forth

(x)

The philosophical water in which everything takes place is both the beginning and the end of the opus, the prima materia, and the Philosophers' Stone. It is a liquid symbol of the Self containing the opposites and turning each one-sided thing into its contrary. Thus it is said, “This (divine) water makes the dead living and the living dead, it lights the darkness and darkens the light” ( CW14: par. 317 )

AOP ¶ 0
(y)

Just as the Philosophers' Stone was identified with Christ, the divine water of the alchemists was also connected with the living water that Christ equated with himself in the Gospel of John: “Whoever drinks the water that I shall give him will never suffer thirst anymore. The water that I shall give him will be an inner spring always welling up for eternal life” ( John 4 : 14, NEB)

AOP ¶ 0

ENCOUNTER WITH

THE NUMINOSUM

(z)

The greater solutio is an encounter with the Numinosum, which both tests and establishes the ego's relation to the Self. As the flood myths tell us explicitly, the flood comes from God; that is, solutio comes from the Self. What is worth saving in the ego is saved. What is not worth saving is dissolved and melted down in order to be recast in new life forms. Thus, the ongoing life process renews itself. The ego that is committed to this transpersonal process will cooperate with it and will experience its own diminishment as a prelude to the coming of the larger personality, the wholeness of the Self

AOP ¶ 0